Member of inappropiate game leads to ban?

We have seen almost everything by KoGaMa now ... 

Damn, you gotta be really stupid to ban all members ... manuel had invited me to some of his games too. But not at the certain one. I remember ... that game wasn't inappropriate until recently. How could the members know? Know what the owner did!


"Sometimes, people have to use their brains"

Literally, you're saying that you would normally ban the members of all of the inappropriate games, but due to the fact you're lazy, you didn't. Sounds fair.

If this is not true, explain why your attitude is so unfair then

Normally, it's the owner's responsibility to ensure there's no inappropriate content in their games when they publish them. If they publish a game with a thumbnail obviously depicting inappropriate content, it's clearly the owner's fault and that should result in a ban. In cases where the inappropriate content is only visible once in-game, the owner is still at fault for letting it through, but it raises the question if a member is responsible for it as well.

I'm not able to view edit history nor timestamps of when players enter projects. At best, I can see if players are owners of models through the log reports, and even then that doesn't tell me who actually edited that model. For me, since I'm unable to determine a clear and definitive culprit for members, I choose to warn them all instead. This works because even if they aren't responsible for creating inappropriate content, they're likely to be discouraged from doing so in the future. Plus, since they are a member of that project, they're just as capable of leaving the project or removing inappropriate content placing some responsibility on them as well. If I find they have been warned about inappropriate content before, then I'll give that member a ban.

So as Daniel said, moderators will have different methods for dealing with rule breaking. Blanket banning usually works because it has a high chance of catching the rule breaking user. It's unfortunate that innocent players will sometimes be affected by it, which is probably the reason why it was only done on low member games.